Is the Market Too Concentrated?


Hi Reader,

Happy 4th of July!

When this email hits your inbox, I'll be drinking cervezas shirley temples on the beach in Mexico with the family.

It's not the most patriotic way to celebrate, but I won't say no to warm weather, tacos, and surfing with the kids.

Thank you for continuing to read and support my work. I appreciate you, and I hope you have a great holiday!

Stay safe, and wealthy. 😊

~Taylor


Concentration Risk

When negative news is scarce, the media often manufactures new worries for investors to consider.

One such worry that I believe follows this formula is the so-called "market concentration risk."

Yes, it's true that today's top ten companies make up a significant percentage of the S&P 500.

But is it a major risk to our portfolios, as so many pundits encourage us to believe?

First, we should ask the question:

"Has the market ever been this concentrated before?"

The unequivocal answer is yes.

If we look at market concentration before the 1980s, high concentration levels were the norm.

Taking this a step further:

"How does the US compare to other developed markets today?"

It's actually (much) less concentrated overall.

According to CNBC, here are the current concentration levels in other major markets:

  • Germany: 57%
  • France: 57%
  • United Kingdom: 50%
  • Canada: 45%
  • China: 42%
  • United States: 35%

I bring these to your attention because almost nobody is sounding the alarms about about these markets being too concentrated.

It's uniquely an American media-driven concern despite the incredible businesses that make up our top ten.

Next, let's consider how incredible these businesses are and how integrated they are into our daily lives.

They're so integrated that avoiding doing business with them is almost impossible.

As an example of this, try to live a week without doing business with Amazon, Microsoft, Google, Nvidia, Apple, or Berkshire, and you'll likely go crazy.

The insane number of products and services these companies produce (or own) helps explain their size and why they represent a large percentage of the U.S. stock market.

If those three points haven't reduced concerns, let's consider one more piece of historical perspective.

Let's go back to the 1970s when concentration levels exceeded today's "worrisome levels..."

"How has the market performed in the time since?!"

Quite simply, the returns have been great.

Since the beginning of 1970 -- which includes two flat decades and three of the words bear markets in history -- the market's average annual return has been more than 10%.

That's not to say that market concentration has never been a risk to investors, just that time was (and always has been) the critical factor in earning satisfactory returns.

Like everything else in the investing world, the market ebbs and flows.

The top ten companies in the '70s are no longer the top ten today, but that didn't mean the market permanently collapsed.

Other companies stepped up and became the big winners, and I'd expect something similar to occur over the next fifty years as well.

This is one of many reasons we believe in owning a widely diversified portfolio of great companies.

We can never know where tomorrow's returns will come from, so we'd be wise to "own them all" over the decades to come.

Stay wealthy,

Taylor Schulte, CFP®

When You're Ready, Here Are 3 Ways I Can Help You:


📊​ Free Retirement & Tax Analysis​. Learn how to improve retirement success + lower taxes.

🎙️ Stay Wealthy Retirement Show​. An Apple Top 50 investing podcast.

🏫 Retirement Podcast Network​. A safe place to get accurate information.

Taylor Schulte

I'm the host of the Stay Wealthy Retirement Show and founder of Define Financial, an award-winning retirement and tax planning firm. When I’m not helping people lower their tax bill, you can find me traveling with my wife and kids, searching for the next best carne asada burrito, or trying to master Adam Scott’s golf swing.

Read more from Taylor Schulte

Hi Reader, If you will allow me some freedom, I want to take a brief detour from my usual topics of financial planning and investing to discuss a controversial subject: politics 😳 But first, did you catch this week's podcast episode? You Are (Probably) Planning for the Wrong Things in Retirement Why are most people planning for the wrong things in retirement? What should they be planning for that they’re not? And why are retirees more depressed than everyone else? Listen Now → Moving Forward...

Hi Reader, Today, I’m sharing seven of my favorite investing & economic charts from the past month. These charts cover topics such as: History of bull markets U.S. economic growth Consumer wages (and satisfaction) ...and more! Let's dive in. 👇 Favorite Charts (October 2024) #1 - This Has Been One of the Fastest Bull Markets in History The S&P’s 63% gain through the first two years makes this the third fastest start to a bull market since the 1940s. Interestingly, the two bull markets that...

Hi Reader, The media loves election season. Unfortunately, this means we’re exposed to countless theories about how the market will react. I’ll save you the suspense (for which there’s plenty of support for this statement below): While the election may be important for other reasons, who ultimately wins probably won’t matter as much to our economy and portfolios as the media would like you to believe. Let me illustrate the truth of this statement by revisiting the last two (highly...